This May be the Safest Way to Play High-Volatility Stocks

Volatility in the stock market isn’t necessarily a bad thing. Investors can reap higher-than-average gains by choosing the right stocks, but they can also suffer greater losses as well. 

Not all stocks react the same way to volatility. Small- and mid-cap stocks in relatively new industries like technology or green energy tend to trade with more volatility than the market as a whole. The key indicator to look for in these stocks is beta. A stock with a beta greater than 1 will, on average, react more strongly, whether positively or negatively, to market activity. 

For example, if the S&P 500 rises by 1%, then a stock with a beta of 1 should rise by 1% as well. However, a stock with a beta of 1.5 would increase 50% more, rising 1.5%. A stock with a beta of 2 would increase by double to 2%. The same applies to drops in the market, which means that high-beta stocks could result in greater-than-average losses.


Of course, you can remove the need to make a bullish or bearish choice on a stock by using an option strategy called a straddle. 

To initiate an option straddle, you buy a call option and a put option at the same strike price and expiration date. This allows you to take advantage of strong price movements without worrying about which direction they go.

The strategy works best on highly volatile stocks or in volatile markets. However, this translates into higher implied volatility in the options, which makes them more expensive. While this can be one of the more expensive option strategies, your profit potential is high without having to pick which direction shares will go. 

The risk is that the stock does not move far enough by expiration to make the trade profitable. But your dollar risk is defined upfront, as you cannot lose more than you paid to initiate the trade. 

Let’s look at a hypothetical example to illustrate how an option straddle works. 

Say you are looking at a stock trading at $25 that you think is primed for a big move but you’re not sure what the outcome will be. You purchase an at-the-money $25 call at $1 ($100 per contract, which controls 100 shares) and an at-the-money put for $0.80 ($80 per contract) for a total outlay of $1.80 ($180 per contract).

The maximum loss you could sustain with one contract is $180, which would happen if the stock expires at $25. To make a profit, the stock must move higher than $26.80 ($25 strike price plus the cost of the trade) or lower than $23.20 ($25 strike price minus cost of the trade). That means to break even the stock must rise or fall by 7.2% by expiration.

So, if the stock reaches $28 by expiration, your put will expire worthless but your call will be valued at $300. Subtract the cost of the straddle and you have a profit of $120. From a percentage standpoint, you would have made 67%. 

Let’s compare it to having owned the stock instead. If you bought 100 shares at $25, you would have paid $2,500. At $28, you would have made the same profit as above — $300 — but without subtracting the cost of the options. However, that’s only a 12% gain and you took on a lot more risk to achieve it.

Remember you looked at the stock because you believed there would be a price movement, but you were unsure of which direction it would go. If the stock fell to $23, you would have lost $200 whereas the straddle would’ve been profitable by $20. 

If you already own the underlying stock, a straddle will work to protect your investment as well as take advantage of opportunities. 

Let’s say the stock dropped to $22 by the expiration date. The value of your stock would be worth $2,200 — a loss of $300. But the straddle will be profitable by $120, limiting your loss to $180. No matter how far the stock falls, the maximum you would sustain is $180 — the same as the straddle without actually owning the stock — because the profits from the put option would offset the loss in the stock.  

The increased profit potential and risk reduction make the option straddle a lucrative strategy when market volatility rises. You can use it to speculate on price movements or protect your investment in stocks you already own. 

Note: If you’re interested in using options to protect the stocks you already own, there’s another strategy you should look into. Did you know you can collect monthly income from “renting” your stock to other investors, boosting your account and offsetting losses in a decline? To learn more about this simple strategy and how you could earn an extra 9%-plus a month, click here.